September 14th, 2009 by ckober
While not quite on the order of Montreal’s Free Agent overhaul, or the complete rebuild in Colorado, the Ducks have undergone a serious retooling this offseason. The trade of Chris Pronger for Joffrey Lupul and Luca Sbisa combined with the acquisition of Saku Koivu represents a shift in the structure of the Ducks roster this year, as well as a number of questions Randy Carlyle will have to consider as training camp started on Sunday in front of a standing room only crowd at Anaheim Ice.
On defense Ryan Whitney and James Wisniewski will have to step up in a big way to fill the shoes of Pronger and Francois Beauchamin. In his first full year as a Duck Whitney will have to prove that he can return to the form he showed in 2007 and 2008 before his injury shortened ‘09 season. Wisniewski’s heart and soul style makes him a great fit to take over for Beauchamin but he’ll have to stay healthy and prove that he can handle the added responsibility and ice time that come with a $1.65 million raise. As Scott Niedermayer is the only defenseman attending training camp who has spent a full year with the Ducks, most of the season previews out there would like to have you think that there is a huge competition for the 4-5-6 spots on defense. I do not belong to that group.
It is true that there are at least 8 contenders for the bottom three defensive slots in the Ducks’ lineup. Of those eight, however, four (Festerling, Sbisa, Mikkelson & Salcido) have played 40 or fewer nhl games, and one (Steve McCarthy) is on a two-way deal after playing in the KHL last year. Having said that, the fact that the Ducks currently have no American League affiliate this year should significantly motivate those on the bubble to have a big camp. With that in mind it has been hard not to notice that Brett Festerling has come to camp looking to be very physical. My money is still on the newcomers. Nick Boynton will bring some size, physicality and veteran presence to the lineup that was lost with the departure of Chris Pronger, as Steve Eminger tries to bounce back after being traded three times since the 2008 draft and youngster Luca Sbisa should round out the top six.
After coming to Anaheim in the Chris Pronger deal, Sbisa trained this off season with Anaheim’s strength and conditioning coach Sean Skahan, whose most recent accomplishment has been whipping Bobby Ryan into shape over the last two summers. According to Curtis Zupke of OCRegister.com Randy Carlyle has taken notice of the 19 year old defenseman’s improvement at the Ducks’ rookie camp which started on Saturday. “He’s starting to develop into a young man, and it’s evident on the ice,” said Carlyle. Similarly in an interview with Kent French on The Element Murray said, “He has all the tools. I think our fans are going to love him. His poise, his body language, how he acts on the ice with the men. He wasn’t intimidated by it. He just fit right in. This kid’s ready.” Through the first two days of training camp Sbisa has played almost exclusively with Nick Boynton. I like the combination of Boynton and Sbisa, from the standpoint that it should allow the youngster to move forward and play more of an offensive role while the veteran Boynton can stay at home. I would ideally like to see Sbisa split some time with James Wisniewski playing alongside Scott Niedermayer. The split would benefit both Sbisa and Wiz by keeping their ice time manageable while playing with and learning from the maestro. Of course Randy Carlyle will look for Sbisa to prove he can take care of his own end before letting him roam around the offensive zone. One small instance of that was his blocked shot on Corey Perry in today’s scrimmage that elicited a few cheers from the Monday morning crowd.
On Sunday I was trying to pay close attention to the newcomers; one that really impressed me was Steve Eminger. In the one on one drill Eminger dismissed the likes of Saku Koivu (who was also very impressive in Sunday’s drills) and Corey Perry with effortless stick work and superior body position. He was less noticeable today, although I only got to see him in the scrimmage. While trying not to put too much stock into line combinations and defense pairings this early, it is worth noting that Eminger played with Ryan Whitney on Sunday, while Whitney was paired with Sheldon Brookbank today. Brookbank tends to be overlooked but can be a solid 5-6 defenseman in this league, but the early indications are that he and Festerling are the frontrunners to be the extra defenseman to be carried on the roster in case of injury.
Switching gears, the offense’s big questions also come in the bottom half of the lineup. Randy Carlyle usually likes to keep pairs of forwards together. With the twins: Ryan Getzlaf and Corey Perry a proven match and the chemistry of Saku Koivu and Teemu Selanne having been established in international play, seemingly all that is left to be decided on the top two lines is whether Joffrey Lupul or Bobby Ryan will play on the first line. Since 2007 the one constant in the Ducks forward lineup was the presence of the checking line of Moen, Pahlsson and Rob Niedermayer. This year none of those three will return as Moen and Pahlsson were traded at the deadline last year and signed elsewhere as UFA’s over the summer and Rob still has yet to find a team to play with this year. Randy Carlyle adjusted his line matching in the playoffs last season, relying on Ryan Getzlaf to shut down San Jose’s first line, going head to head with Joe Thornton. The third line in the coming year should be lead by Todd Marchant at center, and, I would think, Mike Brown on his right wing. Marchant and Brown play a similar style, while Brown brings a little more physicality so they seem to be a natural pairing to try and keep a checking line on the ice. The most competitive spot, possibly on the team, definitely of the forwards has to be the left wing on that third line. Ryan Carter or Petteri Nokelainen on the wing would give the line two natural centers and make it a very formidable faceoff line, which is the first step in being a great checking line. The detriment of having one of those two is that none of those players are particularly large. If the coaching staff was looking for size, they could put the newly acquired Evgeny Artyukhin (6-4, 254!), who is a left shot, up on the third line, but he generally takes too many penalties, and might have trouble keeping up with the speedy Marchant and Brown. I would think that Artyukhin is more likely to be paired with Parros to build an enormous fourth line and keep Brian Burke’s “Big Bad Ducks” reputation alive. The question is if they want to keep that image up.
Bob Murray has on several occasions noted that the main reason that the Ducks did not make it past Detroit last year was an over reliance on Ryan Getzlaf to provide all of the offense. He addressed that over the summer with the additions of Saku Koivu and Joffrey Lupul, giving Anaheim the type of second line we haven’t seen since Andy McDonald was traded in December of 2007. Beefing up the fourth line is one thing for a team who as lost some physical presence on the blue line, but those guys don’t play nearly enough minutes to fill the void of physicality left by Chris Pronger. One of the many options, is for Randy Carlyle to rotate a fourth line pairing of Parros/Artyukhin for the smaller, speedier and much more potent combination of Andrew Ebbitt and Erik Christensen depending on the opponent. For example, when going up against a team without a heavyweight, but with an abundance of offense, like Detroit, the fourth line could be Nokelainen or Carter with Ebbitt and Christensen, but say, Derek Boogaard is in the lineup one night in Minnesota, George and Artie would get the green light. Carlyle also hinted to the possibility of putting Lupul together with Marchant and Artyukhin to try and recreate the Lupul-Marchant-Penner line of the 2005-06 season, which would restructure just about everything I just mentioned. The bottom line is that at this early juncture, with 28 forwards on the roster it is very difficult to judge possible line combinations so we’ll just have to wait and see what kind of chemistry emerges over the next few weeks leading up to the start of the regular season.
There is also the nagging question of goaltending. Will JS Giguere be able to rebound from a tough season where he lost the starting job to Jonas Hiller, or will Hiller prove that he is up to being a true number one goalie in the NHL? This competition, I think will take place more over the regular season however. Randy will most likely go with whoever is the hot hand at the time, but Giguere has made it clear that he will not play a back up role. If Jiggy stumbles out of the gate and Hiller can establish himself we might be looking at a franchise player asking for a trade out of Anaheim, which is a difficult proposition given his salary and no-trade clause.
There is exitement all around this team and decisions to be made everywhere for the coaching staff. It should be a fun run up to the drop of the puck on October third at Honda Center, and that is only the beginning.
Posted in anaheim ducks | 1 Comment »